I agree with the knowledgeable shooters on Weatherby nation. some rifles I shoot boat tails and other rifles I shoot flat base. in general terms it depends on the rifles and ranges you shoot. longer ranges 300 /400 yards plus boat tail bullets come into their own as far as drops go which translates into better B/C's and better retained velocities with lesser bullet drops at greater distances, this all depends on how accurate the bullets shoot to really have any great advantage. I shoot a lot of plain flat base in rifles I don't normally use past 400 yds my own personal opinion flat base bullets tend to be a little more accurate in most of my rifles. some of this kind of bad info on boat tails came from old time shooters back in the day saying that boat tails at times tended to cock the bullet upon exiting the barrel crown caused by non-uniform escaping gases causing a wobble and less accuracy, bad re-loading practices when seating bullets can do the same just in a different way and very possible, back in the day where boat tail bullets may not have been made to the tighter tolerances we have today, the other issue and may have been a bad crown on the barrel itself causing bullets to cock when exiting BUT this will cause inaccuracies with both flat base or boat tail bullets that was a rifle problem. Some folks and you don't see it too often today is re-bated boat tail bullets where you kind of get the best of both worlds so long as the bullets are made correctly the advantage of a boat tail and the squareness of a flat base. the base of the bullet and how square is far more important for accuracy than for instance if you batter the exposed lead tip of a bullet from recoil from bullets in the magazine, or if you knock the lead tip off of a normal hunting bullets while it is most likely not as accurate as undamaged bullets they still shoot pretty well in most cases. one reason why poly tipped bullets or mono (pure copper) bullets tend to fly real well is they are more damage resistant and in the case of pure copper bullets they don't have a jacket with imperfections causing tiny balance issues, not to say solid copper bullets can't be turned out of round which would cause the same problems. I hardly do this any more but I have been known to mic bullets with a .00005 " Mitutoyo that's actually being anal on my part but if they are off .001 out of round or dia spec it could make a difference depending on rifle of course.