Spike Camp

257 wby and elk at 400

257 wby and elk at 400
« on: January 19, 2026, 07:34:52 AM »
 Just the other day I was told you could drop an elk with a 257 Wby and 100gr E-tip at 400yds. That to me is a neck or head shot . The reason being its barely 1300fp of energy when it gets there unless you dont take bone it may not hit what your after. Boy howdy a 270 Wby has just marginal fp/energy with a 130 E-tip at 400yds. I think he is guessing the range on that and never actually measured it off sounds like bs to me.

Grouchy

  • *****
  • 9425
  • Life is too important to take serious" Groucho
    • View Profile
Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #1 on: January 19, 2026, 09:16:55 AM »
The e tip will not expand at those low velocities.

Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #2 on: January 19, 2026, 09:30:25 AM »
We have taken Elk with 257 Wby 110 accubonds usually a lot closer,   25's are great for Deer , Antelope size animals, but Elk is a different ball game.  I really don't go all out for pure energy figures I also look at momentum,  bullet dia,  sectional density,  along with the standards velocity, BC's, bullet constructon,  and mostly from me and my friends past experience, etc.  the perfect shot almost any animal will go down, BUT who always get's the perfect shot, not me that's for sure.  we have friends and their kids that shoot Elk with 243's and it's mostly 150 yds and under and they are good shots,  I won't do it I think it's too light of a bullet really same with the 25's until just lately they are starting to get bullet's in the 130's.  most of the family used 270' Win's ,  my daughter and son-in law use 30-06 and 7mm Rem mag.  the 270's in our case are good to 400 yds give or take and yes we use range finders have for years,  started with the old Ranging 1000's what a pain they were.  now days we have Leica, a couple of Vortex , Had a Leupold which was pretty good until I went to my current  Vortex Fury AB 5000 bino/rangefinder.  one friend now gone used a custom 25 x 300 ultramag at 400 yds on a big bull 1 shot dead.  now days my son and I are shooting Elk at much longer ranges and both use 300 WBY's with 180 gr TTSX @ 3150 fps.  My thought on Elk hunting in general  and I hate chasing Elk down deep canyons basically shoot them until they stop I don't care if they are on the flat in a big meadow or in deep heavy timber or canyons,  use enough gun to get them down,  if they are on the top of a ridge with a canyon below I tell the family or friends I maybe hunting with aim for the shoulder and anchor them,  you are going to take out the shoulder blowout 2 or 3 ribs and front part of the lung,  yes you are going to ruin a bit of meat,  but you are not going to be there for a couple days getting an Elk out.  been there done that more times than I would like.  one year in Eastern Oregon with my Dad and his hunting buddies I shot a nice Elk on top perfect shoulder shot with my dad's 270 win I lend my 270 to another fried because his scope froze, anyway I used my handloads 150 gr Sierra  bullets blew up on the shoulder maybe 70 yds or so, dropped then got up  and shot again in the same place ,   elk got up and ran 2000 ft down a slope and 800 ft elevation drop,  dad's buddy had 5 - 1000 ft rolls of 3/16 th stainless cable so we reeled out 2000 ft of cable clamped together it took 7 of us all stinking day to get that elk out. my son shot a big bull about a mile in on a ridge in the snow and downed trees from a big fire with a 270 Win not a long shot took 2 days to get it out boned out on the last trip out my wife slipped and fell in between 2 downed small trees and broke he ankle  very close to the truck, thankfully guy's had a side by and drove a few yds got her in the side by and into the truck loaded her and to the hospital for surgery took years to heal,  these aren't the only times we have a lot more experiences with getting Elk out,  sometimes I think I'm getting dumber especially with elk   we still do things we shouldn't.   we all got to do it once and then you learn maybe.   moral to the story use enough gun , good bullets , aim good, shoot them till they drop,  and shoot them in a place you can get them out .
« Last Edit: January 19, 2026, 09:52:33 AM by zoniezonie »

Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #3 on: January 19, 2026, 09:47:50 AM »
I agree on the BS unless he just got very lucky. I wouldn't use less than a .270 WBY on an elk even at 200 yards. At 400+, maybe even a .300.
Come and take it.

Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #4 on: January 19, 2026, 10:06:21 AM »
Zoni good advice. I use a 300 Win Mag for elk but unfortunately I lost my bull last year by a bad shot that hit too far back from my usual aim just behind shoulder. I don't know if the bull moved forward just as I squeezed the trigger or I just didn't hold steady. It was only a 200 yard shot but I could not find the bull again in my scope for a followup shot. There were some cows with him and I didn't won't to shoot one of them. It was twilight and we searched but there was no blood trail. Came back in the morning and searched. We figured the bull crossed over on some private property we didn't have access. I've been hunting big game for over 50 years and this was the first animal I have lost. I can tell you it's a bad feeling that I still think about just about every day. Bottom line if I get a shot this year I'm aiming for the shoulder. Maybe ruin some meat but I want to anchor my target and will definitely try to keep looking through the scope after the shot for a quick followup if needed.

Grouchy

  • *****
  • 9425
  • Life is too important to take serious" Groucho
    • View Profile
Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #5 on: January 19, 2026, 11:39:33 AM »
The accubond will expand at distance. The e tip requires much more velocity to open. If I remember correctly, we had the discussion on e tips a long time ago.

Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #6 on: January 19, 2026, 12:19:59 PM »
Some years ago I e-mailed Barnes bullets regarding the 80 gr TTSX I was using in my .250 Savage AI. The reply from Fred Barnes stated that the TTSX would expand reliably at a velocity as low as 1800 fps and that with my muzzle velocity of  3300 fps that made it a 500 yd rifle. Now I'm not going to use that rifle on game at 500 yds, I did harvest a goat at 247 yds.

Weatherby ballistics indicate a Barnes 100 gr TTSX with an impact velocity of2478 fps at 400 yds. I don't know what the impact velocity of a  E-Tip at 400 yds but it shouldn't be more than 100 to 150 fps less. If an E-Tip wouldn't expand at that velocity, why use it?

Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #7 on: January 19, 2026, 12:33:16 PM »
Catdaddy you just never know what will happen sometimes.   years ago a good friend, his son, and an outfitter friend of his,  I know him good guy anyway his son shot a very big bull and hit it high in the chest area broadside,  there is an area on an Elk high on the chest almost like a won't kill them zone ,  there was a little blood trail kind of patchy snow and they lost the blood,  this was the last day of the hunt  he called me gave me perfect directions  asked if we could go find the elk it is about an hour away so my wife and I went up early the next morning and we found where he shot and where the bull was hit we tracked it for awhile until lost the blood also and there were hundreds of elk tracks going every which way so we gave up.  I  almost lost a big raghorn bull I shot the late afternoon  about 70 yds with the 270 & Partitions  great shot  center chest looking at me, unfortunately he had beeen wallowing in the mud and pea gravel and it had dried the bullet blew up but it did damage him,  he took off and we didn't find it so got the flash lights and tracked him until about 1 in the morning we lost the blood trail and finally went back to camp get some rest and start again at daylight.  we were just driving down a 2 track road and I spotted him laying up under a tree  a hundreds yds out or so with his head high  he didn't move  I told my wife and  buddy  I don't think he's dead so I got out of the truck as soon as I opened the door his head moved , so I shot him in the neck and it was over,  he probably went 1 /4 mile from where I shot him the day earlier but when it get's dark it's just hard to track unless there is a lot of blood.  one thing about elk hunting is patience and don't give up.  we were hunting on the Apache Res close to where we live my youngest daughter had a cow tag 14 day hunt  we didn't hunt every day because she was in school the last few days she was getting pretty tired of this stuff and I told her your going to get one just be patient and on the 14 th day she did 40 or 50 yd shot,  she was a happy camper .  she was pretty young,  a couple years later this time she had a bull tag just off the Res last day of the hunt we spotter  small herd in a small dirt water tank about a mile out in the morning , I told my son and her we will come back in arooud 3 in the afternoon and drove them to a place where they could walk in skirting the tree line and a little closer for them to walk , anyway my wife and I drove the truck to a better place we could see better  told the kids if you get one it's going to be at last light so take the flashlights and if we see 2 lights coming out we know you diidn't get one,  if we see one light coming out we know you got one down, anyway just at dark we heard 1 shot and then we waited and we saw 1 light coming out,  I told her if you do get one stay with the elk and her brother would walk and get us,  what happened the herd bull wouldn't come down to the water tank but a big spike and the cows came down the cool thing was the elk came down a little rise just above them and rocks were rolling down on the kids ,  they froze until my daughter using my 300 WBY leaned across my son both sitting down in a bush and she pulled the trigger right up the butt of the spike, didn't ruin any meat we didn't even find the bullet exit wound but it did blow the wind pipe completely out of the elks mouth.  it took me fove ever to get to the water tank with the truck had to cross a small creek we didn't know was there found a treeline  on the other side and snaked the truck between trees and there she was with her elk.
« Last Edit: January 19, 2026, 12:43:33 PM by zoniezonie »

Grouchy

  • *****
  • 9425
  • Life is too important to take serious" Groucho
    • View Profile
Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #8 on: January 19, 2026, 12:33:40 PM »
Years back, Dubyam was touting the e tip and we found out it needs pretty high velocity to open up. The TSX and TTSX don't need that high velocity to expand. Very few bullets need that velocity to open up. With a really good hit, any bullet will work. I would not chose a 25 caliber anything for elk.  ;D

Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #9 on: January 19, 2026, 01:00:56 PM »
I take a lot of whether a bullet is going to open up with a grain of salt,  I look for bullets and I look at how bad  it tears  up the animal.  the only ttsx we recovered from an elk that the family shot was when my son shot a bull at 832 yds a few years back and it didn't open up at all it did take the tip off  I literally could re-load that bullet,  he hit the bull right in the front shoulder broke the off shoulder took out ribs and part of the lung bullet resting on the off side hide.  friends have had pretty much the same experience.   

Grouchy

  • *****
  • 9425
  • Life is too important to take serious" Groucho
    • View Profile
Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #10 on: January 19, 2026, 03:03:11 PM »
Just the flight time of the bullet in any caliber at 832 yrds allows too much time for a critter to move.It's just not my idea of a clean kill.

Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #11 on: January 19, 2026, 03:16:47 PM »
My 257 Weatherby has served me very well for a long time and I have great confidence in the round and the rifle - for deer sized game.

I don’t think I’m good enough to use it on elk unless I was certain to be within 150 yards and it was a broadside shot.
Paul
Don't save the best for last, the smile for later or "Thanks" for tomorrow.

txaggie

  • *****
  • 1602
  • If it bleeds we can kill it
    • View Profile
Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #12 on: January 19, 2026, 04:01:25 PM »
I've seen the debate many times and while i'm as big of a 257 wby fan as anyone as I own more than my fair share and love nothing more than shooting animals with them. Big game hunting I fall into the category with there are better options available. The same well placed 270-7mm-300 or even my fav 340 caliber bullets under good velocity will do more damage and as zonie pointed out. Anchor those big animals as fast as you lethally can - will make for a much better experience. I dont' hunt to prove a point I hunt for fun and the fun ends with lost game or an extensive recovery.

Some buddies of mine went to AZ hunting unit 9 this past late season and it would be the first experience. The guide/outfitter point blank asked my buddy what are you shooting 7mm rem he said how many bullets does your rifle hold? He said our average right now is 6-7 shots fired so keep that in mind. Now he shot a bull probably didn't need the 2nd shot but as directed he placed a second shot in him across a canyon and it was over.

Be prepared for a follow up shot on big critters they can take allot even if they are staggering similar to my nilgai hunt this animal was going down within 10 yards of the first hit and I hit him again ended it. If i have money on the line my pride is taking a backseat - lol

Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #13 on: January 19, 2026, 06:29:35 PM »
I've seen the debate many times and while i'm as big of a 257 wby fan as anyone as I own more than my fair share and love nothing more than shooting animals with them. Big game hunting I fall into the category with there are better options available. The same well placed 270-7mm-300 or even my fav 340 caliber bullets under good velocity will do more damage and as zonie pointed out. Anchor those big animals as fast as you lethally can - will make for a much better experience. I dont' hunt to prove a point I hunt for fun and the fun ends with lost game or an extensive recovery.

Well said.
My avatar here is a Swift A-frame from my .416 Weatherby recovered from a nice 6x6 elk I shot quartering away at a bit under 400 yards.
A .416 may not be needed, but I’d never have considered that shot with my .257.
Paul
Don't save the best for last, the smile for later or "Thanks" for tomorrow.

txaggie

  • *****
  • 1602
  • If it bleeds we can kill it
    • View Profile
Re: 257 wby and elk at 400
« Reply #14 on: January 20, 2026, 05:49:09 AM »
I've seen the debate many times and while i'm as big of a 257 wby fan as anyone as I own more than my fair share and love nothing more than shooting animals with them. Big game hunting I fall into the category with there are better options available. The same well placed 270-7mm-300 or even my fav 340 caliber bullets under good velocity will do more damage and as zonie pointed out. Anchor those big animals as fast as you lethally can - will make for a much better experience. I dont' hunt to prove a point I hunt for fun and the fun ends with lost game or an extensive recovery.

Well said.
My avatar here is a Swift A-frame from my .416 Weatherby recovered from a nice 6x6 elk I shot quartering away at a bit under 400 yards.
A .416 may not be needed, but I’d never have considered that shot with my .257.

Big swift a-frame fan myself i have one recovered from my eland looks just like that from my 340 shot just under 600 yards. Punishing bullet behind weatherby velocities -